The word “picky” is seen too negatively because of its unfair association with food. Being a picky person is seen in a very negative light. Like, you don’t like everything but only specific things. How exactly is that bad? If you think about it in other contexts, though, pickiness can be a little discomforting among a group of people, it is still a very admirable trait to uphold.
While Christmas is the happy and cozy gift giving and receiving time, choosing gifts for the girls becomes a hard task who are most of the time inherently somewhat picky. But what do you give as a Christmas gift for a girl who is very picky? People give things like books, comfortable wear, or even Gift cards as Christmas gifts for girls who are very picky.
Picky people know what they like which in turn shows they know what they want. However, if you fall on the other side of not knowing well or just met this person sometime before, you’re gonna have to be picky with your gift. Here’s the list of Christmas gifts for girls who are very picky, compiled by us.
Cushioned/ Fluffy Socks
$12-$50
Maybe simple socks feel like a boring Christmas gift for a picky girl, but when they’re super cute, fluffy and cushioned socks that can make your heart mushy from the cuteness- Not a boring gift. And the best thing for winters for people who generally end up forgetting their sleepers in other rooms. These socks are the perfect length, slightly above the ankle, and they’re literally so cushiony but still not bulky. Your picky sister or friend will love it.
My Socks may not match but my feet are always Warm.
Naureen Mccullough
Very Specific/Customized Skin-Care Products
$12-$80
Many new websites and apps now conveniently deliver customized skin care products at your doorstep. Anything that is remotely related to us automatically makes our eyes shoot hearts. Imagine getting a specially customized skin care product as a Christmas gift for a very picky girl.
Even she wouldn’t be able to stop feeling overwhelmed from the amount of gratitude. If you see or meet this person daily, this is a highly thoughtful present for this picky person as you get to see the condition of their face daily. You can easily do a skin survey for them and get a customized product for them.
Your Skin needs a detox just like your body except that it needs it more often.
Skin Exfoliant
$10-$50
A Skin exfoliant with good elements like Bha, Aha and Salicylic acid is such an ideal skin exfoliating product to give as a gift. These are incredibly effective and specially for teenagers dealing with acne breakouts every third day. This is a perfect Chritsmas Gift for a very picky girl which could be your little sister, daughter or BFF.
The best Foundation you can wear is a Glowing Healthy Skin!
A Gift that symbolizes a special connection/ secret
$-Variable Price Range
For your dear loved girl or bestie, anything that could remind them of a special memory only you two share. Something that works as an inside joke or inside talk. It could be a place, a word, any special object, as long it is something you both give a meaning to. This can go for anyone you are extremely close enough to share such moments with.
This is a wonderful idea for Christmas gifts to give girls who are very picky as even the pickiest people love things that have special meaning to it. You can even gift a book with underlined or highlighted words that you want to convey. This can be a creative method with guarantee to make your girl smile.
A holder
$10-$55
If you want to keep it simple and decorative , you should consider a holder with some cute candies, marbles or any sort of decorations inside. A holder can basically work as whatever this picky girl wants to make it. A pen stand, A kitchen tool stand, a match holder, or anything.
Once done with finishing the goodies inside, this holder can be a multipurpose thing. This is something anyone can use but very few people own or realize its need. Be the one to point this need out. You can put assorted colored sweets or pens to give this as a Christmas gift to a very picky girl. Works well for students or younger ones.
I am not a Seller. I am a Holder.
Marcus Lemonis
Knitwear
$20-$200
Knitwears just have something different about them. Like the cozy feeling of home and your people the moment you put one on. Knitwear especially reminds me of vintage clothing which is a loved style even today. This is the fall in love at first sight kind of Chritsmas gift for girls who are very picky. But you need a bit of courage to choose one for your girl. If you can afford the Luxurious brands, they have some really good knitwear.
In a balloon of Yarn is the potential to make a dream you have, come true.
Melanie Falick
Indulgent Stationery
$10-$150
One of the many necessities of gifting comes with the responsibility of finding a gift that the giftee would love and also enjoy using in everyday life. For such matters, indulging stationery is a very great choice. Now this can be anything as the scope of stationery is very big.
But one of the best Christmas gifts for very picky girls is journals, letter pages and envelopes, stickers and more. With the variety and theme you can find a product for anybody’s taste. You can add in custom stamps or vintage look ink pens. This is a very valuable gift for the younger girls and also you can use this with your daughter or sister and write letters to each other.
A Girl can Never have too much stationery.
Embroidered Linen Napkins
$24-$150
Picky or not, moms are famous for being very bad giftees, gifting-wise. It’s either “This is too expensive” or “What a waste of money, i could have bought it for much less”, “You got duped”, and the list goes on. Perhaps.. a set of linen napkins embroidered with initials or the holiday embroidery?
If you’re lucky enough to find a Vintage monogram napkin, good enough. You get to brag- “According to the seller, these were embroidered 150 years ago in London”. If not, Amazon/Esty/Ebay will help you find it. Else you can go to a thrift store and try your luck.
Luxury lives in the finer details. It’s a cloth napkin on the dining table. It’s a mint on your pillow before bed.
Iggy Azalea
Charming Coasters
$25-$60
This is a great gift idea to give your senior or superiors or even mom. Moms love anything that helps decorate the house and for acquaintances and not very close people, it’s not something specific but good enough to be used by them. Coasters are something specific that most people would want but most probably don’t have.
If someone is into interior and decorative stuff you can opt for marble coasters. For a more cozy look and feel, try wool coasters or wood coasters. Wool ones can absorb condensation so they don’t have to be wiped more and can be washed easily in the washer.
Don’t Ruin my table. Use a coaster!
A Box of Seasonal Fruit
$20-$70
For the health conscious picky girl who’s always counting calories or on diet. I think box of seasonal fruits or their favorite fruit can be a good idea. This can be a healthy Christmas gift for pocky girls who are diet conscious. Also, eating fruit never hurt anybody.
In case they eat fruits regularly, getting this picky girl a subscription or delivery of a box of seasonal fruit salad or just two or three seasonal fruits can be a good idea. Even if she doesn’t eat it daily, making them start a good habit would not be that bad of an idea.
The Branch might seem like the fruit’s origin. In fact, exists because of the fruit.
Rumi
Expensive/Luxurious items
$1000+
Now, not everyone can buy Louis Vuitton and Chanel but for those out there who can afford to, get into gift buying mode, go through the stores and gift something that your picky girl can’t possibly dislike. From purses to rings, pendants and necklaces, dresses to shoes, go the extra mile to find their wishlist and gift that thing to her. No woman ever said no to luxury when given the opportunity. Nothing is too much when you’re spoiling someone with gifts.
Luxury never goes out of Fashion
Classy glasses with a map of a Favorite place/ Hometown
$14-$50
If your mom/ wife/ friend is from a different country or city or even town, this is a great way to remind them of their Hometown. Sometimes we all feel homesick and even a little bit of resemblance can be emotionally overwhelming. Perfect Christmas gift for a picky girl to bring some nostalgia but also to let them know they’re not alone.
Life takes you unexpected places. Love brings you home.
Memory foam slippers/ slides
$20-$120
Cute animals, sleepers that are very comfortable. The best combination ever. Also, nobody needs to know your goofy side as you’re going to wear this at home. Keep that strong girl image outside and be the cute goofy girl at home because who’s gonna see anyway? Memory foam helps in comfort for the feet. The cute animals are just the cherry on top for your picky girl’s eyes to adore.
Home is where you keeo your Slippers!
A chic and timeless scarf they can style in countless ways
$15-$100
Scarves remind of the old movies where the heroine sits on the open air Mercedes wearing these cute satin scarves over the head and the long drives. To help a picky girl channelize their inner heroine, it’s not a bad idea to get them a pretty scarf which adds glam to any outfit and protects hair when worn on it. This is a cute Christmas gift for a picky girl to be the main character of their story.
When I wear a silk scarf I never feel so definitely like a woman, a beautiful woman.
Audrey Hepburn
A gift card/ subscription service
$20-$150
With the amount of online platforms, delivery services nowadays; the bills have increased with the extra costs of these apps. One of the feasible ideas could be paying for a subscription or buying a gift card that could help with discounts. Netflix is the entertainment of today and Food delivery apps are life and time savers. Getting a subscription is the most sensible gift ever.
You deserve to splurge a little!
A cool kitchen/ cheese board
$30-$75
Another kitchen/ home essential that your mom or wife and you would love too. Who doesn’t like to have tools like a chef when cooking? This is a must have Christmas gift for a picky girl who loves to cook her own food. If she’s a food vlogger, Voila! These boards can come single or with a pack of knives and other kitchen tools. See which one would be most useful and gift your picky cook.
I’m Cutting Carbs!
A journal/ planner to get work done
$20-$90
A gratitude journal helps get those weird thoughts running in your brain out. A very healthy way to relieve your overwhelming thoughts. A planner basically makes you want to cross those things off you wrote, making you more productive. For the procrastinator in the picky girl, these are really helpful. A perfect blend of mindfulness and productivity.
Fill your paper with the breathings of your heart.
William Wordsworth
A book to fill with reasons why you love them
$10-$50
You will have to put some extra effort into this, but the results will be absolutely amazing. Order a blank book or notebook meant especially for these messages or get one from a store. Fill it up with reasons you love your picky girl (Remember to include pickiness as a reason too), gift wrap it and give them as a Chritsmas Present. This will be the sweetest thing you can give a girl and it would even melt the picky ones. Because who doesn’t like being made to feel special?
There is never a time or place for true love. It happens accidentally, in a heartbeat, in a single flashing, throbbing moment.
Sarah Dessen, The Truth About Forever
A Snuggly throw blanket made with cozy material
$40-$150
Christmas means the winter season! What’s better than a snuggly blanket to cut the cold? Blankets are literally the most used items of winters. And what’s better than being able to sit anywhere without thinking about the cold. A throw blanket feels like a warm hug- a perfect cozy Christmas gift for girls who are very picky.
Christmas is a blanket that warms our cold hearts.
Toni Sorenson
A casual minimalist smart backpack
$ 30-$150
Backpacks come really helpful in day to day traveling with the amount of things they hold for us. Laptops, books, notebooks, clothes bottles. To make it even better, we now have smart backpacks as well that are anti-theft and have charging ports so you have a portable charger built in your backpack. Some even have LED light displays. A great safety Christmas gift for your picky daughter/ sister or friend who uses public transport on a daily basis.
I am nicer when my bag fits all my items.
Funko Pop- favorite anime/cartoon character/fictional character
$3-$30
For millennials it’s Harry Potter, for Gen Z it’s Euphoria and Brigerton. No matter what generation the nerds love funko pops of their favorite characters. There is a reason Marvel heroes, Harry Potter characters have such products because of crazy fandoms that buy anything remotely related to such characters. This is a cute Christmas gift for a picky girl who is so into such characters. Like even Fendi bags wouldn’t compare to the character funko pops for them.
Everyone is a fan of something!
An ancestry kit for exciting history
$50-$89
Family history is an interesting topic to learn from grandmothers and grandfathers. So what if you could know what your ancestral roots are? Maybe you had roman roots, who knows. Anyway this is such an exciting thing to do for even an adult, imagine how exciting it would be for the younger ones. Let your picky girl know her history and be the queen if there was one in your family.
It is in the roots, not the branches, that a tree’s greatest strength lies.
Matshona Dhliwayo
A mug that everyone would love to drink from
$10-$30
These cute mugs come with a small animal 3-D figure that can be kept in the mug and you can pour your drink over it. Reveal your cute little animal as you finish your drink. This would definitely make someone swoon over. Sweet and cute Chrtismas gift for very picky girls because nobody is immune to cuteness.
You can never have too many mugs of your favorite beverage!
A powerful animal bottle stopper
$10-$30
Gothic designs or Dark designs, lifelike, perfect for showing your taste. These bottle stoppers are a noble setting to decorate your home with. Also, you can get a whole pack of bottle stoppers with different styles. This is one of those things that people would see in 5 minute crafts or Buzzfeed Videos as “Hacks You wish you Knew”.
Wine is bottled Poetry.
Headphones that are as pretty as they are practical
$50-$350
Again, headphones are like the one thing that we use everyday. But rose gold is one of the cute colors that are now used in most devices. Sure enough, small air pods are pretty convenient but for the girls that love the feeling of covering their ears to listen to music, it is nostalgic and fun. This is a very cool and everyday use Christmas gift for girls who are very picky.
Headphones In. World Out.
A Polaroid camera for the hidden photographer inside them, and an additional photo album for storing those polaroid memories
$50-$200
What’s the one thing girls love about a polaroid? It makes them realize their dream to act like Taylor Swift in her music videos. Plus, even the pickiest people love her and so do they love the things that remind of her.
Polaroids are great Christmas gifts for girls who are very picky as this is one of the ways to preserve memories in the form of photographs or snaps. Smartphones do have enough space for photos but the feel of a photograph is just another thing.
We keep this love in a photograph. We keep these memories for ourselves.
Ed Sheeran
Super Hydrating body lotion to defeat winter dry skin
$7-$75
The one thing you need every Christmas is a good moisture retaining, super hydrating body lotion to get rid of that winter dry skin. Self-pampering gifts are very loved as they can be general but still loved by the giftee. You can never go wrong with a skin caring gift.
I am a better person when I am Moisturized.
A Food subscription to Boxed meals/Treats
$10/week +
If your picky girl is a very busy person and does not have time for much cooking, this is a fulfilling Christmas Gift for a very picky girl who’s also very busy. Most food subscription services come with a package of home cooked meals or healthy meals, fruits, treats and desserts. You can pay for one month of subscription as a gift and if they love it, extend it for them. This way your picky girl will have warm healthy meals daily instead of fast food and instant food.
It’s okay to treat yourself with food!
Delicate, personal earrings with shapes/words/initials that are meaningful
$5-$35
Earrings are found in every girl’s possession and it’s one of those things most girls love. Since, it requires to be changed to coordinate with outfits, gifting a pair of earrings, that too personalized ones that can go along with most of the everyday clothing is a very smart move. It is a very subtle but personal enough Chritsmas gift for a girl who is very picky. Who doesn’t like their name initials on their things?
You can always tell what kind of a person a man really thinks you are by the earrings he gives you.
Audrey Hepburn
A sleek water bottle that fits in everywhere and makes you stand out
$25-$75
Fitting water bottles in purses can be problematic when they take up too much space. A sleek water bottle can be handy when you are carrying mid size purses instead of a big bag. This takes up very less space and you can always just refill it instead of buying plastic bottles, so less plastic waste. Also, the cool design would be a great conversation starter.
Take a sip Right Now!
Customizable T-shirts so they have their favorite phrase or photo on it
$20-$90
T-shirts with cool texts or graphics are the go to casual wear for comfort. What if you could customize your own T-shirts? This is one of the coolest ideas for Christmas gifts for girls who are very picky. You can literally use a phrase this girl speaks the most and make a gift out of it.
Luxury is the ease of a t-shirt in a very expensive dress.
Karl Lagerfeld
A subscription to daily Flowers/ Bouquet delivery
$-Variable Price Range
Receiving flowers has always been loved by girls even if it’s just a single rose. Just something about flowers that makes you feel like the special queen you are. But you can’t possibly go buy flowers daily when these flower shops are scarce and usually not very easily found.
But technology made it easier for you. Just get on a flower delivery app and get custom or package flowers/ bouquets delivered to your picky girl every morning. That would make her day and also remind her of you. If you’re the special someone, this is a really romantic idea to try.
A flower’s appeal is in its contradictions — so delicate in form yet strong in fragrance, so small in size yet big in beauty, so short in life yet long on effect.
Terri Guillemets
Cute/ Cool Stickers, because the child inside is always alive!
$5-$35
No matter how old you grow, those small sticker decorations on anything still make you swoon. Let’s be honest, cute things can never be unlikable even if they are cheesy or cringe. Also, if it’s your favorite marvel character or a cartoon you used to love, even better your favorite Anime character, it’s going to be absolutely treasured. Cute stickers are a really good Christmas gift for picky girls who are young kids or even for adults with their own obsessions.
It’s the little things that make a huge difference.
A smart photo frame that syncs to the phone and displays a slideshow
$80-$499
Physical photographs have lost their popularity but photo frames still occupy our hearts. A smart photo frame is one step ahead of normal ones though. You can choose which photos appear, for good quality, no blur pictures being displayed. Also, you can start a slideshow in it with the motion sensors help. An amazing way to display as many pictures you want without having to struggle with removing old photographs.
You can frame a moment. But you can´t frame life.
Armin Houman
A donation in their name to a cause close to their heart
$-Variable Amount
The best gift for any person could be to make a contribution to a cause they are more biased for. Especially people with difficult or bad childhoods, having a contribution in their name would make them feel your sincerity and your understanding of what they stand for.
The value of life is not in its duration, but in its donation. You are not important because of how long you live, you are important because of how effective you live.
Myles Munroe
Here in the below table we have made the list of gifts that will be easy for you to purchase.
Conclusion
Pickiness shows that the person knows what they like and dislike very clearly. This trait makes picky people a good and bad receiver of gifts. If you’re someone close to this person and know them for a while to have an understanding about certain things they like or dislike, picking a gift is an easy task as you don’t have to struggle searching. However going for extra efforts to pick Christmas gifts for a girl who is very picky will never do you harm, instead only strengthen your relation with this girl.
Bharat Suthar
I am Author and Principal Creator of Christmasgiftsjustforgirls.com. I am passionate about making people aware towards the value of gifts in life. Here I share information about different gifts for girls of different nature.